Abstract
-
The article represents a comprehensive reconstruction of biographies of Mongol military commanders who led campaigns against the state of Koryŏ in 1218–1260. Noting that the general chronology of the military campaigns of this period has been covered in considerable detail in world historiography, the author aims to fill the gap concerning the identities of these commanders, their origins, and their place within the military hierarchy. The source base of the study comprises Korean and Chinese chronicles and historical works: Koryŏsa, Koryŏsa chŏryo, Tongguk p’yŏnggam, Yuán shǐ, Yuán shǐ shìzú biǎo, Yuán Gāolí jìshì, Kē Shàomín’s Xīn Yuán shǐ, and Huáng yuánshèng wǔ qīnzhēng lù, as well as The Secret History of the Mongols and works of Rashīd al-Dīn and Juvaynī.
As a result of a comparative analysis of the source texts and their collation with existing historiographical literature in Russian, English, Korean, and Chinese, the biographies of ten military commanders, who successively or simultaneously led incursions onto the Korean Peninsula, have been reconstructed with varying degrees of reliability: Qachi’un, Saritai, Púlǐ Dàiwán, Tege-Qorči (Díjù), Tangut, Amuqan, Yěgū, Čelodai, Fuboda, and Yesuder. All of them held high command positions, ranging from leaders of embassies and major military campaigns to commanders of thousand-strong units who participated in negotiations. Among other findings, their heterogeneous ethnic composition was revealed: among them were representatives of the Genghisid lineage, the Jürchen nobility, and individuals from various Mongol tribes. The collected information can fill the lacuna regarding the individuals who determined the course of Koryŏ history in the 13th century and make a new contribution to the study of the early stage of Mongol-Koryŏ relations.
-
Keywords: Koryŏ, Mongol State, military campaign, Genghis Khan, Koryŏsa, Qachi’un, Saritai, Púlǐ Dàiwán, Tege-qorchi (Díjù), Tangut
Introduction
This article
1 represents the first reconstruction of biographies of the Mongol military commanders who participated in various stages of the conquest campaigns against the state of Koryŏ in 1218–1260. The study of biographies and military careers of Mongol commanders who operated on the Korean Peninsula in the mid-thirteenth century is not merely a prosopographical exercise but also opens broader perspectives for understanding the mechanisms of imperial governance, military logistics, and interethnic interactions within the Mongol State and later the Yuan Empire. The role of these military leaders in the history of Koryŏ extends far beyond purely military operations: they served as the primary agents of the khan's will, and their negotiations, ultimatums, and punitive actions directly shaped the terms of peace settlements, determined the degree of autonomy enjoyed by the Koryŏ polity, and influenced the factional struggles at the Koryŏ court between proponents of armed resistance and advocates of capitulation. Behind each campaign stood specific individuals from diverse tribal and clan backgrounds, whose personal ambitions, kinship networks, and standing within the military hierarchy frequently determined not only tactical decisions but also the diplomatic tenor of relations with Koryŏ. A reconstruction of their life trajectories allows one to move beyond the abstract chronology of events and to observe how Mongol imperial policy was refracted through the prism of individual choice, inter-clan rivalries, and local circumstances, as well as how the actions of particular commanders at various stages of the invasions predetermined the trajectory of Koryŏ dynastic survival in the face of Mongol pressure.
The general chronology of the Mongol campaigns of this period has been covered in detail in Russian, Western European, and South Korean historiography; however, insufficient attention has hitherto been paid to the identities of the commanders, their origins, and their place within the hierarchy of the Mongol army. To address this lacuna, materials from the following Korean and Chinese chronicles and historical works were studied:
Koryŏsa (高麗史,
History of Koryŏ [
State], 1451, sections 世家세가 “Annals of Generations” and 列傳열전 “Biographies”)
2,
Koryŏsa chŏryo (高麗史節要,
Essentials of Koryŏ History, 1452),
Yuán shǐ (元史,
History of Yuan [
Empire], 1370),
Tongguk pyŏnggam (東國兵鑑,
Military Overview of the Eastern State, mid-15
th century),
Yuán shǐ shìzú biǎo (元史氏族表,
Genealogical Tables of Clans and Lineages [
Mentioned in]
the History of Yuan [
Empire], 14
th century),
Yuán Gāolí jìshì (元高麗紀事,
Chronicles of Koryŏ [
State]
in the Yuan Era, 1407/9; in this article we used the version published by Wén Tíngshì in 1917), and
Xīn Yuán shĭ (新元史,
New History of Yuan [
Empire], 1920) by Kē Shàomín. The text of
Mongɣol-un niɣuča tobčiyan (
The Secret History of the Mongols, or
Yuáncháo bìshǐ 元朝秘史,
The Secret History of the Yuan Dynasty,mid-13
th century) was also examined. As supplementary sources, Rashīd al-Dīn’s
Jāmi’ at-tawārīkh (
Compendium of Chronicles, early 14
th century), ‘Alā’ al-Dīn ‘Aṭā Malik Juvaynī’s
Tārīkh-i jahān-gushā (
History of the World Conqueror,1260), and
Huángyuán shèngwǔ qīnzhēng lù (皇元聖武親征錄,
Description of the Personal Campaigns of the Sacred-Martial [
Emperor]
of the August [
Yuan Dynasty]) in the Russian translation by Archimandrite Palladius (Petr I. Kafarov) were consulted.
A total of ten commanders’ biographies have been reconstructed. These individuals, either in succession or concurrently, commanded military campaigns in Koryŏ, and it should be noted that these are the entirety of Mongol commanders who ever came to Koryŏ before it became the vassal of the Yuan empire in 1259, as it may be found in historical sources. They were of diverse ethnic origins and held various military ranks; all are mentioned in Koryŏsa, while information concerning some of them in other sources is either fragmentary or entirely absent. Unfortunately, the amount of information available on each of them varies considerably. For instance, Saritai is mentioned numerous times across all the sources consulted, with detailed accounts of his activities and even recorded statements, because he, unlike others, took part in campaigns on the Korean peninsula for many years and played, among other things, a leading role in the formation of the idea of the need to move the ruling family and government to Kanghwa island in an attempt to avoid confrontation with the Mongols, and was also actually the first to command real full-scale military operations against Koryŏ. Whereas for other commanders, such as Fuboda, almost no information survives, consequently, the sections of the article devoted to them differ significantly in length.
This article adopts a chronological framework for presenting the figures under investigation, irrespective of their ethnic background or the length of their sojourn in Korea. The research is divided into two parts, covering the periods before and after 1232, when the refuge to Kanghwa Island occurred. This event can be regarded as a pivotal turning point in the relations between Koryŏ and the Mongol state. To a great extent, it was the very location of the court and the king that determined the nature of relations between the Koryŏ government, represented by the military dictators of the Ch'oe clan, and the Mongol commanders leading campaigns against the peninsula. Accordingly, the first section, covering 1218–1232, includes Qachi’un, Saritai, and Púlǐ Dàiwán, while the second section, covering 1232–1259, comprises the remaining seven commanders.
Mongolian Commanders Leading Campaigns Against Koryŏ
Qachi’un
The first Mongol commander who arrived on the Korean Peninsula in 1218 was likely the younger brother of Genghis Khan (Temüjin, 1162?–1227, Qa’an of all Mongols from 1206), the third son of Yesügei-
ba’atur and Hö’elün: Qachi’un (or Khachi’un, Mong. Qachi’un-elchi, 1166?–1218/9?). In Chinese and Korean chronicles, his name is transcribed as 何稱 Héchēng (Kor. 하칭 Hach’ing / K’ach’iun) or 哈眞 Hāzhēn (Kor. 합진 Hapchin)
3. Qachi’un received from his powerful elder brother the seventh most important position in the hierarchy, following their mother Hö’elün, the four sons of Temüjin, and his brother J̌oči-Qasar, precisely in that order. Notably, while other brothers of Genghis Khan, such as J̌oči-Qasar (Mong. Qasar? ᠬᠠᠰᠠᠷ? 1164?–1219?) and Temügeotčigin (Mong. Temüge? ᠲᠡᠮᠦᠭᠡ? 1168?–1246), are frequently mentioned in
The Secret History of the Mongols as loyal comrades-in-arms of their elder brother, Qachi’un is rarely spoken of, not only in accounts of political and state affairs but also in ordinary dialogues concerning daily life. Rashīd al-Dīn wrote of him as follows: “The third son was Qachi’un. He had many wives and sons, and his deputy was [his beloved son] Elčidei (Alchidai, Eljigidei, late 1180s–1252. –
Auth.). He enjoyed great esteem. Ögedei, Möngke Qa’an, and Qubilai Qa’an always valued and respected him, consulting him on important matters. His ulus and yurt are located in the eastern part, directly to the east, within Mongolia, near the borders of that wall which the Khitai stretched from the Qara Müren [Yellow River] to the sea of Jurje
4”
5. In
The Secret History, it is merely noted that “when Temüjin was nine years old,<…> Qači’un Elči was five”
6. The compilers of the modern Korean translation of
Koryŏsa (2006) from the Sŏktang Research Center at Dong-A University (ROK) also observe that Qachi’un’s son Elčidei and the descendants of Temüge-otčigin made Manchuria their sphere of influence
7.
The statement by Rashīd al-Dīn: “Since Qachi’un died young without acquiring much renown”
8, has shaped the scholarly opinion that Qachi’un may have passed away early, as his name is absent from chronicles describing later events in the life of Genghis Khan. For instance, Valery A. Zlygostev dates his death to approximately 1195/1196
9. However, the nearly verbatim recurring mentions of Qachi’un in
Koryŏsa,
Koryŏsa chŏryo and
Yuán shǐ, pertaining to the end of 1218, may serve as evidence that he was still alive at that time and actively engaged in operations on the Korean Peninsula, holding the position of supreme commander of the Mongol army. It is not improbable that he fulfilled a largely representative, but mostly formal and ceremonial function, as “he held the high title of
zhòuwáng [紂王, prince] <…>, signifying a member of the
Golden Lineage”
10, while the de facto commander attached to him was Saritai, an outstanding person who will be discussed in detail below.
The first mention of Qachi’un appears in an entry of
Koryŏsa under the 12
th month of 1218, in the account of the Mongol attack on the northern frontiers of Koryŏ: “After the Mongol commanders Qachi’un and Ch’ara (i.e. Saritai. –
Auth.) led ten thousand soldiers and joined forces against the Khitans with the twenty-thousand-strong army of Wányán Zǐyuān
11, sent by Púxiǎn Wànnú
12 of Eastern Xia, they <…> proceeded directly to the Kangdong Fortress (Kangdongsŏng, present-day Kangdong District, P’yŏngyang. –
Auth.)”
13. As is known, during the battle of Kangdong, the combined Mongol-Jürchen army assisted the Koryŏ troops in defeating and expelling the Khitans from the country. In return, however, the Mongols demanded the establishment of inter-state relations in the form of
sadae (事大사대, lit. “serving the great”), the Confucian form of vassal-suzerain foreign relations between states, wherein one assumes the position of “elder brother” and the other that of “younger brother”, and the payment of an enormous annual tribute.
Koryŏsa chŏryo records Qachi’un’s words: “The Emperor (Genghis Khan. –
Auth.), because the Khitan forces have hid in your country now for three years and you have never been able to eradicate them, therefore, he has sent troops to pacify them. Your country should help only with provisions without deficiency. <…> The Emperor commands, that after destroying the enemy we should make a treaty to be older and younger brothers”
14. The Koreans were compelled to agree, yet they continually delayed the dispatch of successive embassies, withheld tribute, or supplied the Mongols with goods of inferior quality and in far smaller quantities than demanded – circumstances that led to protracted investigations spanning three years.
In
Yuán shǐ, Qachi’un is first mentioned in a brief entry from 1218 (the 13
th year of Genghis Khan), which also concerns his arrival in Koryŏ to participate in the campaign against the Khitans: “The Khitan [Yēlǜ] Liúgē
15 captured the Jiāngdōng stronghold in Koryŏ; [Genghis Khan] ordered Qachi’un and Saritai to lead troops to subdue him”
16.
Yoon Eun-Sook has compiled three perspectives regarding the purpose of Qachi’un and Saritai’s incursion into Koryŏ that currently exist in South Korean historiography: “Ko Byŏngik (고병익 1970, p. 160) argued that they entered Koryŏ territory in the process of pursuing Jurchen troops. Chu Ch’aehyŏk (주채혁 1977, p. 300) viewed it as a preliminary reconnaissance operation, and Yun Yŏnghyŏk (윤용혁 1991, p. 28) believed it was part of a joint military operation against Jin”
17. Overall, these perspectives are not mutually contradictory.
Certainly, it cannot be fully asserted that Qachi’un directly commanded military operations in Koryŏ or that he should be termed a “military commander” in the strict sense; nevertheless, we cannot overlook his role in the events that preceded the Mongol incursions into the Korean Peninsula, and we therefore deemed it necessary to include him among the figures examined in this study. Moreover, the details of his biography pertaining to the Korean campaign have hitherto received little scholarly attention, as researchers have generally focused on his domestic political activities in Mongolia as a member of Genghis Khan 's family.
Saritai
According to
Yuán shǐ, Qachi’un apparently died in the 9
th month of 1219
18, and the post of supreme commander was assumed by his chief assistant, Saritai.
Yuán Gāolí jìshì records under 1219 (14
th year of Genghis Khan, Emperor Tàizǔ 太祖): “Koryŏ dispatched officials <...> with a letter proposing peace to the military camp of Zhálà (i.e., Saritai –
Auth.). <...> Zhálà sent a reply, confirming his agreement to the peace”
19.
Saritai is perhaps the most interesting, yet enigmatic, figure of that era; in terms of the number of mentions in Korean and Chinese chronicles, he surpasses collectively all other Mongol commanders of the pre-Yuan period, which allows for a fairly detailed tracing of his activities on the Korean Peninsula in specific years. A comparison of the texts has shown that all information pertaining to his biography is, in one way or another, contained in
Koryŏsa, while other sources, including later Chinese works, repeat – sometimes verbatim – fragments of the Korean chronicle. Despite the fact that the
Yuán shǐ was compiled almost a century earlier than
Koryŏsa, Chinese historiographers paid extremely little attention to Saritai, mentioning him only in passing. A few unique records were found in
Koryŏsa chŏryo and
Yuán Gāolí jìshì. In
Koryŏsa itself, information is also repeatedly duplicated in “Annals of Generations” (世家세가) and “Biographies” (列傳열전) sections.
Xīn Yuán shĭ is the only source that contains a biography of Saritai (named J̌ači’ertai Qorči in
Xin Yuan shi), together with a number of other figures: Taču (son of Saritai), Ajuru (Ačinai), Huaidu (grandson of Ajuru), Tagai Ba’atur (Taqai), Atahai, Süke Qulan (Kereit), Shiliukai-Noyan, Maili-darqan, and Širegi
20. However, it also represents merely a detailed compilation of information from earlier chronicles. Thus,
Koryŏsa can rightfully be considered the main source of information on the life and activities of Saritai.
All surviving information regarding Saritai’s activities is recorded in
wényán (文言, also Kor. 漢文 한문
hanmun), with the Northern Chinese official dialect serving as the pronunciation norm
21; the phonetic transcription of his name (the meaning of the characters was not taken into consideration) varies across chronicles and works by different authors, and even within different sections of the same chronicle compiled in different years:
– In Koryŏsa and Koryŏsa chŏryo: 札剌 (Ch. Zhálà; Kor. 찰라 Ch’alla; this variant also appears in Tongguk pyŏnggam), 撒禮塔 (Ch. Sǎlǐtǎ; Kor. 살례탑 Sallyet’ap), and 撒里打火里赤 (Ch. Sǎlǐdǎ huǒlǐchì; Kor. 살리타화리적 Sallit’a hwarijŏk), as well as 箚刺 (Ch. Zhácì; Kor. 차자 Ch’aja). In this last variant, which occurs only once in an entry from 1233, the character 刺 cì is used; it is visually very similar to 剌 là, which was evidently due to errors made during copying or the preparation of woodblocks. This same character is used in Xīn Yuán shĭ (see below);
– In
Yuán shĭ: 撒里塔 (Ch. Sǎlǐtǎ), 撒里荅火兒赤 (Ch. Sǎlǐtǎ huǒérchì), 札剌台 (Ch. Zhálàtái), 札剌兒 (Ch. Zhálàér; Igor de Rachewiltz notes that such a name could have been borne by both Khitan and Jurchen military commanders
22), 撤里台 (Ch. Chèlǐtái), and 撤兒台 (Ch. Chèértái);
– In Yuán Gāolí jìshì: 撤里答 (Ch. Chèlǐdá) and 撒里塔火里[赤] (Ch. Sǎlǐtǎ huǒlǐ[chì]);
– In Xīn Yuán shĭ: 札刺亦兒台[豁兒赤] (Ch. Zhácìyìértái[huōérchì]);
– In Yuán shǐ shìzú biǎo: 札剌儿 (Ch. Zhálàér).
It should be noted that in
Koryŏsa,
Koryŏsa chŏryo, and
Yuán shĭ, in the entries for the years 1218–1221 and in the biographies of officials who participated in the events of that period (e.g., Cho Ch’ung, 1171–1220
23), his name is recorded as “Ch’alla / Zhálà”, whereas after 1231 it appears exclusively as “Sallyet’ap / Sǎlǐtǎ”; this is the origin of the most well-known Latin and Russian version of his name, “Saritai”. However, in every mention from 1231–1233 of the Khitan incursion of 1216, in which the Mongol army participated (see above), we consistently encounter the name “Ch’alla / Zhálà”. This may be a consequence of the fact that, firstly, the initial records of
Koryŏsa, which guided the authors of other chronicles, were compiled by different historiographers, and secondly, that the compilers of the later entries copied information from earlier fragments without subjecting it to doubt or reinterpretation.
– In
The Secret History of the Mongols, Saritai is mentioned only once and is referred to as J̌alayirtai Qorči
24, and, judging by the context, his activities pertain to a later period, which will be discussed in detail below.
Regarding the etymology of Saritai’s name, there is no consensus, since, as indicated above, it was recorded using Chinese characters. Only the following can be stated with certainty: Saritai’s epithet – Ch.
huǒlǐchì, Kor.
hwarijŏk – is pronounced as
qorchi (Mong. ᠬᠣᠷᠴᠢ) in Middle Mongolian and means “quiver-bearer”, “arms-bearer” (Rus. “колчанщик,” ”оруженосец”),
25 therefore, some authors refer to him as “quiver-bearer”. For instance, Valery A. Zlygostev, in the chapter “Saritai. The Tormentor of the Koreans”, notes: “Judging by the prefix to his name
qorchi, that is, ‘archer’ or ‘quiver-bearer’, he followed a path of ascent up the hierarchical ladder typical for many Mongol commanders (who bore the same honorary prefix), having begun his service in the
kešig guard already under Genghis Khan. Later, with the rank of commander of a thousand, he fought in Northern China by order of Muqali (see below. –
Auth.) in 1221. <...> By the early 1230s, Ögedei (2
nd Great Qa’an of Mongolian State, Emperor Tàizōng 太宗, 1229–1241. –
Auth.) entrusted Saritai with command of the campaign in Korea”
26. Saritai’s biography in
Xīn Yuán shĭ notes: “He served as a guard for Taizu (Genghis Khan). In the 12
th year (1218), Hāzhēn (Qachi’un) was appointed supreme commander, and Saritai was his deputy, leading the Mongol army”
27.
It is known that in 1217, six years after the first attack on the Jin, Genghis Khan transferred operational control over all lands seized from the Jurchens to Muqali (Mukali-goyon, Muhuri, Mong. Mühülei?, ᠮᠣᠬᠣᠯᠢ?, Ch. 木華里 Mùhuálǐ, 1170–1223), one of his “four nökörs”(closest companions, alongside Bo’orču, Boroqul, and Čilaun)
28, who was appointed the Great Khan’s viceroy in Northern China from 1217 to 1223, and bestowed upon him the title 國王
guówáng (“ruler”, “prince of the appanage”). Muqali hailed from the J̌alayir tribal confederation (J̌alayids, Mong. J̌alair, J̌alaid, Mongols or Mongol-Turks), who in the 12
th century inhabited the banks of the Onon River. As mentioned above, when the Mongols conquered the Manchurian region, the younger brothers of Genghis Khan, J̌oči-Qasar and Temüge-otčigin, received these lands as their possessions. In fact, after Muqali’s death in 1223, authority over the Liáodōng region and Manchuria became entrenched among the descendants of J̌oči-Qasar, Qachi’un, Temüge, and Muqali. Thus, it was the J̌alayir tribe that led the conquest of Northeast Asia, during which Saritai invaded Koryŏ. Archimandrite Palladius (Petr I. Kafarov), in his translation of the manuscript
Huángyuán shèngwǔ qīnzhēng lù (
Description of the Personal Campaigns of the Sacred-Martial [
Emperor]
of the August [
Yuan Dynasty]), notes that “2,000 cavalry of the J̌alar” participated in the campaign against Korea
29.
Chu Ch’aehyŏk suggests that “Saritai is not a personal name, but a phonetic rendering of the word ‘J̌alayir’ <...> since the true Mongols used the names of their tribes as personal names”
30. This assertion can be cautiously agreed with, considering the naming of Saritai in
Xīn Yuán shĭ as Zhácìyìértái[huōérchì], where the first word precisely denotes the J̌alayir tribal confederation (allowing for an obvious scribal error in the second character, mentioned above). Furthermore, Chu Ch’aehyŏk, citing
Yuán shǐ shìzú biǎo, asserts that Saritai belonged to the J̌alayir clan, which played a key role in the conquest campaigns against Koryŏ under Genghis Khan, Ögedei, and Möngke (4
th Great Qa’an, Emperor Xiànzōng 憲宗, 1251–1259)
31. Dugvema N.-D. Zhapova states that among the Mongols, “in the formation of anthroponyms, appellatives characterizing any properties of the named person, circumstances of their birth, etc., are taken as a basis”, and further: “Nicknames as a type of anthroponym perform communicative functions in the language alongside personal names.<...> They fall into the category of non-ceremonial naming...”
32, which also generally confirms the theory of the origin of the name (or nickname) Zhálà / Saritai from the ethnonym.
Furthermore, Chu Ch’aehyŏk argues that it was customary for the Mongols to indicate a clan name (corresponding to a Chinese surname) and a personal name, unique to each individual. Together, they constituted a person’s full name. In his view,
Ch’alla is nothing other than a personal name, while
Saritai is a clan epithet. This is precisely why, during the campaign of 1218, serving as deputy to the supreme commander Qachi’un, he appears in the chronicles under his personal name, whereas in 1231–1232, when Saritai had already assumed the position of army commander (元帥, Ch.
yuánshuài, “supreme commander”), he began to be recorded under his clan name, as the chief representative of the J̌alayir clan
33. Chu Ch’aehyŏk presents the following arguments: “There are two possible explanations for ‘Sarita’ being a clan name and ‘Ch’alla’ a personal name: 1) during the period of the military campaign against Koryŏ, he acted as the sole representative of the J̌alayir clan (札剌兒氏), so the clan name Sarita / J̌alayir was used; 2) after returning to the Mongol capital, where other influential representatives of the same clan might have been present, his personal name Ch’alla was used in official documents to avoid confusion. That is, the difference in names is explained by context: military chronicles used the clan name, while court documents used the personal name”
34. He also asserts that “J̌alayirtai in
The Secret History of the Mongols is not a distorted transcription of the name Sarita (撒兒台), but simply a different phonetic rendering of the same name”
35.
However, Chu Ch’aehyŏk’s theory that
Ch’alla is a personal name may be called into question, primarily due to its phonetic similarity to the ethnonym “J̌alayir”. Moreover, it can be assumed that the Korean chroniclers may not have known his real name at all, since it was for some reason taboo, especially for subordinate foreigners, and they used the well-known ethnonym instead. This is indirectly confirmed by an entry from 1221, when Qachi’un had already died and Saritai’s status had clearly risen to that of a commander, but the naming remained unchanged: “[The envoys] also presented letters from general Ch’alla”
36.
Thus, it can be asserted with a high degree of probability that Zhálà / Ch’alla and Saritai are two variants of the same tribal name, and Saritai-qorči can be interpreted as “Archer from the J̌alayir tribe”.
It should also be noted that some researchers mistakenly refer to Saritai as
Sartak (or
Sartaq), for example, William Henthorn
37, Remco Breuker
38 and Edward J. Shultz and Hugh H.W. Kang in their translation of
Koryŏsa chŏryo39, or
Sarta, like Gari Ledyard
40. Not only does such a transcription of his name appear nowhere, but it could also lead to incorrect associations of Saritai with Sartaq (?–1256), the second ruler of the Ulus of Joči (1255/1256), the eldest son of Batu, and great-grandson of Genghis Khan. Rashīd al-Dīn in his
Jāmiʿ al-tawārīkh also mentions several times a certain Sartaq-Noyan, whose grandfather or father (unclear) Saba originated from the J̌alayirs and was a companion of Genghis Khan; possibly, Saritai appears here under the name “Sartaq”: “When Genghis Khan fought the Markit nation and they were victorious, Borta Fujin was pregnant with J̌öči (this refers to J̌öči, Genghis Khan’ son, not his brother J̌oči-Qasar –
Auth.). The Markits carried her off as booty, and since at that time there was peace between the Markit and Ong Khan, they sent her to Ong Khan, who held her in honor and respect. <…> When Genghis Khan was informed of this, he sent Saba, the grandfather of Sartaq-Noyan of the J̌alayir tribe, to Ong Khan to request the return of the lady. Ong Khan complied and turned her over to him. Jochi was born while they were on the road back to Genghis Khan, and because the road was dangerous and there was no place to stop and make a cradle, Saba kneaded a bit of flour dough, wrapped the child in it, and took him on his lap to protect him and keep his limbs from harm...”
41. It cannot be ruled out that such a significant service rendered to Genghis Khan by Saritai's closest relative, among other things, contributed to his becoming close to the Great Qa’an and helped him build his subsequent career. However, it cannot be ruled out that usage of the name “Sartaq” may be caused by the use of different romanization systems in the 1960-s rather than by incorrect association.
The next mention of Saritai appears in an entry from the 8
th month of 1221, when Mongol envoys led by Zhùgǔyŭ
42 arrived at the Koryŏ court to inquire into the circumstances surrounding the delay in tribute. Among other things, they delivered a message to the king on behalf of Saritai and another Mongol commander, Púlǐ Dàiwán (see below for more details), demanding to be provided as tribute with otter skins, silk, and cotton
43. Saritai himself was not part of the embassy; evidently, his status by this time was already much higher.
After the murder of Zhùgǔyŭ in 1225, official Mongol missions did not visit Koryŏ until 1231. This long hiatus was most likely the result of internal political strife within the Mongol state following the death of Genghis Khan in 1227and the accession to power of Qa’an Ögedei. Then, ten years later, in 1231, mentions of Saritai reappear in
Koryŏsa, leading a campaign against the recalcitrant state that refused to pay tribute: “The Mongol military commander Saritai surrounded Hamsinjin and thoroughly trampled Ch’ŏlchu (modern Ch’ŏlsan county, P’yŏngan-Pukto Province. –
Auth.)”
44.
After the Mongol army led by Saritai crossed the Amnokkan river in the 8
th month of 1231, it apparently had two routes for advancing south. The first was the main road in the northwest of the peninsula, which passes through Yŏngju, Ch’ŏlchu, Kwakchu, crosses the Ch’ŏngch’ŏngang River, and reaches Anju and Sogyŏng (P’yŏngyang); the second was an inland road to Sŏgyŏngvia Kwiju (Kuju, modern Kusŏng, P’yŏngan-Pukto Province). Saritai chose the second route; the army moved from Hamsijin towards Kwiju and, on the 3
rd day of the 9
th month, surrounded the fortress. However, they were unable to capture it and retreated, though causing serious destruction
45. It is curious that Archimandrite Palladius, when mentioning this campaign in his translation of the chronicle, seems to “split” Saritai into two persons: “From here, he sent Sahata and Qorči to conquer Gāolì”. However, he subsequently refers to him as “Sardaqorchi”, evidently drawing no parallels between these personages
46.
In the 11
th month of 1231, “
Pukkye pundaeŏsa (Inspector of the Northern Region) Min Hŭi <...> reported the following: ‘I <...> received an order <...> and went to the Mongol camp to offer food. At that time, the commander, [who calls himself]
quán huángdì and is known [by the name] Saritai, was sitting in a leather tent decorated with silk, and his wives stood in rows to his left and right’”
47. The aforementioned term
quán huángdì (權皇帝, Kor. 권황제
kwŏn hwangje), where the character 權
quán literally means “invested with authority” and can be interpreted as “ruling emperor”. Nikolai Ts. Munkuev translated it as “temporarily acting emperor”, and noted that this title was first bestowed upon Muqali
48, indicating that such a practice already existed previously. Apparently, over the course of ten years, Saritai had risen significantly in the hierarchical ladder, from deputy and companion (essentially, a bodyguard) of Qachi’un to the All-Mongol Qa’an’s viceroy in Koryŏ. Indeed, in the following entry from the 12
th month of the same year, it is noted: “At that time, Saritai was at the Protectorate for Pacifying the North (安北都護府 Ānběi dūhùfŭ, or Anbuk Regional Military Commission
49, established in Tang China in 647 and responsible for relations with Inner Mongolia, the lands of the Uyghurs, the Tiele tribes, etc. –
Auth.) and sent three envoys to urge [the king of Koryŏ] to submit. <…> The Emperor sent [to you] the army of Saritai-Qorči, [to ask] whether you will surrender or wait until you are killed. In the Year of the Rat (1216), the Black Khitans invaded Koryŏ, [and when you] were unable to properly expel them, [we] sent two men, Ch’alla and Kach’iun, to lead an army, capturing and killing all the Black Khitans”
50.
Koryŏsa chŏryo additionally notes that after some time, King Kojong (高宗 고종, 1213–1259) sent his relative, Prince Hwean Wang Chŏng (淮安公王侹 회안공왕정), to Saritai with gifts and food, and the latter hosted a banquet: “Chŏng presented food. Sartaq offered him kusmiss and delicacies. Chŏng at once was able to eat and drink all that was urged to him. Sartaq was very pleased”
51.
Shortly after the banquet (possibly on the occasion of the approaching New Year), the king twice sent gifts to the sons of Tangut, T’ege-Qorchi (for more details on them, see below), and Saritai, including numerous silver and gold items, silver ingots, textiles, otter skins, and clothing
52.
Tongguk pyŏnggam also notes: “All the gifts sent by the state [of Koryŏ to the Mongols], as well as the offerings [given] to Saritai and [other] military commanders, cannot be listed in detail”
53. In the 3
rd and 4
th months of 1232, gifts and letters from the king were sent to Saritai again, requesting a reduction in the amount of tribute, particularly otter skins, as Koryŏ was unable to supply such a volume of goods, and also asking for the revocation of the humiliating demand to send youths and maidens to the Mongol court.
54
In the 5
th month of 1232, the Koryŏ government, led by the military strongman Ch’oe I (崔怡 최이, aka Ch’oe U 崔瑀 최우, 1219–1249), began discussing radical methods to counter the Mongol threat. Consequently, it was decided to move the king and his family to Kanghwa Island, and to relocate the population of the northern regions, which were most vulnerable to attacks, to sea and river islands that would be difficult for the nomads to reach. When Saritai learned of this, the Mongol army prepared to storm the capital Kaegyŏng (modern Kaesŏng, Hwanghae-Pukto Province). In this situation, King Kojong – or rather, more accurately, the military government of Ch’oe U – unable to devise a plan for further resistance, accepted the peace terms proposed by the Mongols. These terms, on Saritai’s initiative, included the placement of “overseers”, or
darughachi, representatives of the Khan’s headquarters to supervise the officials installed in the conquered areas within Koryŏ territory. As a condition for withdrawing his troops, Saritai demanded that 72
darughachis be distributed across 14 of the most important regions of the Northwest Territory (Sŏbukkye), including Sogyŏng (P’yŏngyang). Then, in the 12
th month of 1232, as is known, the Mongols resumed military operations against Koryŏ and laid siege to the settlement of Ch’ŏin
pugok (處仁部曲 처인부곡, or Ch’ŏinsŏng, 處仁城 처인성) in the suburbs of Suju fortress (modern Suwŏn, Kyŏnggi Province). It was there,on the 16
th day of the 12
th month, that Saritai was killed by an arrow shot by the monk Kim Yunhu (金允侯 김윤후).
55
After Saritai’s death, the Mongol authorities mentioned him only three times in official correspondence. In 1233, they sent an angry message to Koryŏ king beginning with accusation of Saritai’s murder: “Your first sin [is that] after subjugating the Khitans and killing Ch’aja, you never sent an envoy [with explanations] to our court”
56.
Yuán Gāolí jìshì notes that Saritai was mentioned twice in decrees sent from the Mongol state for admonition and intimidation. The first time was in 1240 (12
th year of Ögedei–Tàizōng 太宗): “[Although] Héchēng and Zhálà are already dead, [do I] not know the affairs [that they] conducted? All the participants in these events [are still] alive”
57, and in 1249 (4
th year of Güyük–Dìngzōng 定宗), 17 years after Saritai’s death: “[Do you] think that with the death of Héchēng and Zhálà I do not know their deeds? I am not a child to be deceived! All your crimes: expelling envoys, killing Zhùgǔ[yŭ], refusing in
imjin year (1232) to follow Saritai against [Púxiǎn] Wànnú, and fleeing to the island, – are evident”
58. These decrees skillfully combine accusations, admonishments, and direct threats, structured for maximum psychological impact, and show that the Mongols attempted for a long time to use Saritai’s death as an additional tool of pressure on the Koryŏ authorities. Nevertheless, this appears to have had no direct negative consequences for the Korean population of Koryŏ.
The last chronological mention of Saritai is found in the aforementioned biography of Mongol military commanders in
Xīn Yuán shĭ, in the life account of “J̌alayirtai’s son’ Taču (塔出): “Taču, the son of a meritorious official, in the 17
th year of the Zhìyuán era (1280), received the title of
Zhāoyǒng dàjiàngjūn (昭勇大將軍, ‘General of Shining Valor’. –
Auth.) and was appointed
darughachi of the Eastern Capital (Dōngjīng, aka Kāifēng, Liáoyáng. –
Auth.) administration. <...> In the 22
nd year (1285), he appeared at an audience, and the Emperor (Qubilai Qa’an, Emperor Shizu 世祖, 1260–1294. –
Auth.) conversed with him at length, asking: ‘Do you remember the decree of Genghis Khan given to your father, J̌alayirtai?’”
59. The time difference between Saritai’s death and Taču’s conversation with Qubilai is almost 50 years, so it can be assumed that the son of the Mongol commander was born shortly before or maybe even just after his death. Nevertheless, the mention of Genghis Khan clearly indicates that this refers specifically to Saritai, and not to Čelodai (for more on him, see below).
Púlǐ Dàiwán
Púlǐ Dàiwán – the next commander who visited Koryŏ as an envoy; his name first appears in conjunction with Saritai in the aforementioned entry from the 8
th month of 1221, when Mongol envoys arrived at the Koryŏ court to inquire into the circumstances surrounding the delay in tribute. Púlǐ Dàiwán (蒲里帒完, Kor. 포리대완 P’ori Taewan, ?–?) took active part in the battle at Kangdong[sŏng] fortress. Fragmentary information about him exists only in
Koryŏsa, where he is also mentioned under the names 蒲黑帶 (Ch. Púhēidài, Kor. 포흑대 P’ohŭktae) and 蒲桃 (Ch. Pútáo, Kor. 포도 P’odo); he also appears briefly as Púlǐ Dàiyě (蒲里帒也) in
Yuán shǐ60. Determining his ethnic affiliation is impossible. It has been established that earlier, in 1219, as part of the Mongol embassy led by Qachi’un, he arrived in the Koryŏ capital Kaegyŏng and, in violation of etiquette, rode his horse into the courtyard of the guest house, and later, during an audience with King Kojong, refused to perform the official bow and attempted to take the ruler by the hand
61. Later, Púlǐ Dàiwán, under the leadership of Saritai, participated in the campaign against Koryŏ in 1231–1232. Specifically, in the 11
th month of 1231, he took part in the attack on P’yŏngju, as simultaneously recounted in
Koryŏsa,
Yuán shǐ, and
Tongguk pyŏnggam: “The Mongol army approached the Sonŭimun gate in P’yŏngju and set up camp. The commander P’odo camped at Kŭmgyo (modern station in Kaesŏng district, Sŏhŭng county, Hwanghae-Namdo Province), the commander Chŏkkŏ (see later. –
Auth.) camped at Osan, and the commander T’anggu (see later. –
Auth.) camped at Pori. The enemy’s vanguard reached the Yesŏnggang River, burned an innumerable number of houses, and killed people. The residents of Kaesŏng were shocked and enraged, and riots broke out”
62. Subsequently, information about the life and activities of Púlǐ Dàiwán is nowhere to be found.
During the same campaign, the high-ranking military commanders Tege-Qorči and Tangut distinguished themselves; apparently, after the completion of the raid on P’yŏngju, they remained in Koryŏ territory and somehow participated in negotiations with the Koryŏ government: “The King sent people to deliver gifts to the sons of T’anggu, Chŏkkŏ, and Saritai. <...> The King presented to the commander T’anggu a jar with an engraved seal on the lid, a set of cup holders, two rolls of fine hemp cloth, a dun horse, a silver-plated saddle, and an embroidered saddle”
63.
Mongolian Commanders Leading Campaigns Against Koryŏ till Recognizing Vassalage to the Yuan Empire (1232–1259)
Tege-Qorči and Tangut
Tege-Qorči (迪巨 Díjù, Kor. 적거 Chŏkkŏ, 帖哥火魯赤Tègē huǒlǔchì
64, Kor. 첩가화로적 Ch’ŏpka hwarojŏk, ?– after 1275) was a Jurchen, the eldest son of the founder of Eastern Xia, Púxiǎn Wànnú, mentioned above. It is interesting to note that in
Koryŏsa he is referred to as Chŏkkŏ, while in
Yuán shǐ he mostly is called Tègē or Tègē huǒlǔchì, and once Díjù
65. In 1216, his father sent him to the Mongol state as an honorary hostage: “[In the 11
th year of Emperor Tàizǔ (Genghis Khan)] in the 10
th month of winter, Púxiǎn Wànnú surrendered and sent [his] son Tege to serve as a court attendant”
66. Subsequently, no information about him appears until the Korean campaign of 1231 (see above). Later, in 1235, Tege-Qorči was transferred to Shǎnxī and Sìchuān to participate in the attack on the Southern Song. In 1247, when the Mongol army attacked South Song, Tege-Qorči,in the rank of the Great Marshal (元帥
yuánshuài), held the first position among the generals under his command; in 1254, he entered Sìchuān also as Great Marshal; in 1262, he participated in the campaign against Jiādìng Prefecture (modern Lèshān City, Sìchuān Province); and in 1275, Tege-Qorči, already advanced in age, was sent to guard Huādōng
67.
In contrast to Tege-Qorči there is no single definitive version regarding the biography of Tangut/Tangu. With certain caution, we can assume that Tangut (Tangu-
ba’atur, Tangqut, Ch. 唐古 Tánggǔ, Kor. 당구 Tanggu, Mong. Tanγut, 1210s – after 1246) was a member of the Mongol ruling clan and the sixth son of J̌öči (ca. 1177/78–1227), the eldest son of Genghis Khan and founder of the Ulus of J̌öči. Together with his brothers Orda and Batu, Tangut, among other things, participated in the conquest campaigns against Russian lands and Eastern Europe, which began just after the conclusion of the Korean campaign of 1231–1232. In Juvayni’s
History of the World Conqueror, when describing the commanders of the Western Campaign of the Mongol Empire, it is mentioned that three from J̌öči’s lineage participated in the campaign: Batu, Orda, and Tangut
68. Considering that Orda was the commander of the left wing, and Batu was the nominal supreme commander of the expeditionary army, it can be assumed that Tangut held the position of commander of the right wing during the campaign. Rashīd al-Dīn mentions that the Iranian governor of the Mongol Empire visited the Ulus of J̌öči, first paying a visit to Tangut, whose nomadic camps were located on the route from the Kipchak steppe through Khwārazm to Khorasan, extending from the Mangyshlak Peninsula west of Khwārazm to the Emba River basin, and then returned to Khorasan via Khwārazm
69. This indicates that Tangut possessed his own forces, independent of Batu. According to Valery A. Zlygostev, “after Saritai’s death, it was Tangut who, by order of [Qa’an] Ögedei, led the Mongol conquest campaign in Koryŏ in 1236, but subsequently departed for the west and in the autumn-winter of the same year fought in Volga Bulgaria, after which, apparently, he returned east (it is not excluded that he was wounded)”
70. This is repeatedly noted in Russian historiography as well (using the Korean pronunciation of his name): “<...> In 1236, a new Mongol army under Tangu invaded Koryŏ. <...> For more than two years, Tangu’s army remained in Koryŏ, plundering and devastating villages and cities”
71; “The Mongol troops under the command of General Tangu carried out the third invasion of Koryŏ after the complete defeat of the Jin Empire and simultaneously with the ‘Great Western Campaign’ (i.e., against Rus’ and European countries) – in 1235–1239”
72. The authors and compilers of the translation of
Koryŏsa also note that “the leader of the Mongol invasion forces at that time was Tangu, and the war continued until the 26
th year of King Kojong’s reign (1239). At that time, after the destruction of the Jin dynasty, the Mongol Emperor Ögedei convened a
quriltai (supreme council) near Qaraqorum, where he decided to conquer unsubdued territories. The main targets were the western regions, the Southern Song, Tibet, and Hindustan. Tangu’s invasion of Koryŏ was part of this conquest war”
73. Next time his name appears in the records of
Koryŏsa in 1241: “Tangu sent four men. <...> Tangu also sent eight men...”
74. It is also known that in 1246, Tangut was present at the
quriltai that elected Güyük as great Qa’an (r. 1246–1248); there is no later information about him.
There is also another point of view on the biography of this person: authors of Korean translation of
Koryŏsa note that “details about Tangu’s origins are unknown. Considering that there was a Tang tribe in the Jin state, it is quite possible that he was a Jurchen. Taking into account the aforementioned assertion by Chu Ch’aehyŏk that Saritai is a [modified] name of the J̌alayir tribe, as well as the practice of using tribal names as personal names at that time, such a possibility is entirely real”
75. William Henthorn, speaking of Tangut-
ba’atur, similarly asserted that “Tangut certainly refers to the eponymous people from the Xi Xia state”
76, that is, he believed that the commander’s name originated from the toponym Tangut
77, and that he himself was a descendant of a people annihilated by the Mongols. Unfortunately, due to the lack of information in the chronicles, it is not possible to definitively determine his identity and ethnicity at the current stage of research.
Amuqan and Yegü
In 1247 (the 2
nd year of the 3
rd Qa’an Güyük, Emperor Dìngzōng 定宗, 1246–1248/51), the fourth invasion of Koryŏ was led by the commander Amuqan (阿毋侃 Āmóukǎn, Kor. 아모간 Amogan, ?–?), who had replaced Tangut. He led the army to Yŏmju and set up camp, reaching the capital Kaegyŏng
78. Kē Shàomín also indicates that Amuqan visited Korea a second time in 1252
79, but
Koryŏsa and
Koryŏsa chŏryo date this event to the 4
th month of 1253: “Amogan and Hong Bogwŏn
80 reported to the Emperor that Koryŏ had built a fortified stronghold and did not intend to surrender. The Emperor ordered his younger brother Songju (松柱 Sōngzhù, Kor. 송주 Songju; possibly referring to Ariq Böke, Mong.Аригбөх, 1219–1266. –
Auth.) to lead a 10,000-strong army, which was to proceed east through Chinju and reach the eastern border. Amogan and Hong Bogwŏn led their troops to the Northern Region and encamped at T’aeiju”
81; “<...> Also presented gifts to the commander Amogan”
82. It can be cautiously assumed that the chronicles refer to Anmuhai (ca. 1180s – after 1254), a Mongol from the Barghut tribe, the first chief of Genghis Khan’s stone-throwing artillery, who borrowed this technology from the Tanguts and successfully applied it from the early 1200s. From the mid-1210s, he participated in campaigns in Northern China under the command of Muqali; after 1229, he accompanied Ögedei on conquest campaigns in China; and in 1253, Qa’an Möngke “issued [to Anmuhai] a tiger-headed
paizi (corresponding to the rank of commander of ten thousand. –
Auth.), promoting him to supreme commander”
83, and sent him west under the command of
zhūwáng (諸王, prince) Hülegü. Overall, this does not contradict the chronology of his, apparently brief, stay in Korea. In February 1258, Anmuhai probably participated in the storming of Baghdad, but no more reliable information about him exists.
In the early 1250s, Prince Yegü (也窟大王 Yěkū
dàiwáng, 也古諸王 Yěgū
zhūwáng, 也苦 Yěkū, Kor. 也古諸王 야고제왕 Yago
chewang, ca. 1190s – after 1254) appears on the military scene of the Korean Peninsula. He was the eldest son of J̌oči-Qasar, a nephew of Genghis Khan, and a fifth cousin of Qa’an Möngke. According to Roman P. Khrapachevsky, “if it is not him, then one could assume it was either his nephew or grand-nephew – the fact is that J̌oči-Qasar had more than 40 sons and, according to Rashīd al-Dīn, their names are not recorded and are unknown, except for the names of the three most important ones. Among their sons and grandsons, there could well have been those named after Yegü, who was the senior member of J̌oči-Qasar’s lineage at that time”
84. In 1251, he supported Möngke’s accession to the throne, and already in 1252, he received an appointment to the high position of supreme commander: “In 10
th month [the Emperor] issued an order to Prince Yegü to march on Koryŏ”
85. However, at the beginning of 1253, Möngke relieved Yegü of command of the troops in the campaign against Korea due to a scandal involving an attack on the camp of the prominent commander Tačar, appointing Čelodai (on whom see below) as commander of the eastern army
86. In an entry of
Yuán shǐ from 1253, Yegü is referred to as a “great general” (大將
dàjiàng) and it is stated that he besieged the city of Dàlǐ (大理, modern Yúnnán Province) together with Muqali’s grandson Ba’atur:“In the 12
th month, on the
bingchen day, the army approached the city of Dàlǐ. <…> [The Emperor] ordered Yěgū
dàjiàng and Batu’er to pursue [them]”
87. At the same time, according to
Koryŏsa, throughout 1253, despite his dismissal from the Korean front, Yegü corresponded with the Koryŏ court regarding the return of King Kojong from Kanghwa Island to Kaegyŏng: “Yegü sent 16 envoys. <...> The King welcomed [them] at Chep’ogung [palace] and presented [them with] gifts of gold, silver, and cloth according to their rank”
88; “The Mongol commander Yegü sent a man to deliver the Emperor’s decree to the King... <...> The King sent a reply letter to Yegü’s camp. <...> At that time, Yegü was in T’osan (modern Chunghwa county, P’yŏngyang. –
Auth.)”
89; “
Taejanggun Ko Yŏl was sent with a letter to
t’aewang Yegü. <...> [Along with the letter], gifts were sent: gold and silver drinking vessels, various kinds of silk, hemp cloth, otter skins, hats, and belts”
90. Since the dismissal happened in the 1
st month, it is possible that he was reappointed in the following month but was not recorded in the dynastic history, before records about him appear in
Koryŏsa in the 5
th month.
Already in the autumn of 1253 (8
th month the earliest), Qa’an Möngke again appointed Yegü as the supreme commander of the forces in Korea, and he captured a number of fortresses; as before, the Mongol invasion was accompanied by extreme terror and mass looting. The destruction wrought by the Mongol army caused great concern among the local ruling elite. In a letter addressed to Yegü, King Kojong expressed bewilderment over the attack and, attempting to halt the Mongol offensive, emphasized that Koryŏ was already in a vassal position. In the 11
th month, Yegü departed north, leaving Amuqan and Hong Bogwŏn to guard Ch’ungju, because in 1254 a
quriltai was to convene in Mongolia, at which Yegü’s presence, as the oldest representative of the
Golden lineage (he was then at least 60 years old), was apparently mandatory
91. When, in 1253, King Kojong temporarily returned to Kaegyŏng from Kangwa island, it was an extraordinary envoy on behalf of Yegü who was the first among the Mongol nobility to greet him at the new palace Sŭngch’ŏnbu and conveyed the following words: “Ever since our troops entered Koryŏ territory, tens of thousands of people have died every day. How could Your Majesty care only for yourself and not for the lives of the people? If you had come to us earlier, how could innocent people have perished so horribly? The words of
t’aewang Yegü are the words of the Emperor, and my words are the words of
t’aewang Yegü. How wonderful it would be if we could establish peace and friendship from now on and forever!”
92 After 1254 there is no information about Yegü in the chronicles.
Čelodai
After Yegü’s departure, the position of supreme commander of the Mongol army in Koryŏ was finally taken by Čelodai (ca. 1190s – after 1259), a figure whose origin and activities cause some controversy among orientalists. He is first mentioned in the records of
Koryŏsa from 1254: “The Mongol Emperor entrusted Ch’aradae with [matters] concerning Koryŏ”
93. In Korean and Chinese chronicles we have studied, his name is recorded consistently as車羅大 (Ch. Chēluódà, Kor. 차라대 Ch’aradae). At the same time, the variant 札剌兒帶 (Zhácìérdài) also appears in
Yuán shǐ, 劄剌亦兒 (Zhálàyìér, i.e. J̌alayir) in
Koryŏsa, and there is a single mention of J̌ala’irtai-Qorčin in
The Secret History of the Mongols94, which gives some reason to doubt whether this figure might be Saritai – that is, the same commander who fought on the Korean Peninsula in 1218, 1231–1232, and also in the 1250s? In the historiography of the Soviet period, the argument in favor of this was the view of Sergei A. Kozin and a number of other Mongolists
95 that
Mongɣol-un niɣuča tobčiyan was created in the 1240s, so it could not possibly have reflected the Korean events of the second half of the 1250s, in which Čelodai was the main protagonist. However, the prevailing opinion now is that
The Secret History was largely recorded by 1240 and then supplemented during the reign of Qa’an Möngke, i.e., roughly in 1251–1259. Gari Ledyard
96 and Igor de Rachewiltz
97 also maintain the view that Čelodai’s campaigns occurred precisely in 1254–1259, in accordance with the records of
Koryŏsa,
Koryŏsa chŏryo, and
Yuán shǐ; that is, Saritai and Čelodai are different people, especially since
Koryŏsa clearly records the circumstances of Saritai’s death. The exact date of Čelodai’s death is found in
Tongguk pyŏnggam: “In the 5
th month [of 1259], Ch’aradae suddenly died”, and
Koryŏsa: “
Pukkye pyŏngmasa informed that Ch’aradae suddenly died”
98.
Chu Ch’aehyŏk
99 believes that Čelodai was a younger tribesman of Saritai, and similarly derives his name from the ethnonym J̌
alayir, since in the 1250s he became the central figure representing the tribe during the conquest campaigns, as Saritai had done earlier (Čelodai’s campaigns are also described in detail in the above-mentioned Russian studies). Valery Zlygostev also highlights Čelodai as a separate figure in the section “J̌alayirtai-Qorčin. Conqueror of Korea”: “From the J̌alayir tribe. (Born ca. 1190s, died after 1258.) Judging by his nickname Qorčin (‘archer’), he began his service in the
kešig guard. According to the register of Mongol troops, at the turn of the 1210s he is listed as a commander of a thousand of the left wing (commanded by Muqali). <...> For many years he fought in Korea and possibly participated in the Mongol invasion of that state in 1231. After Saritai’s death in 1232 and the weakening of the conquerors’ pressure on the state of Koryŏ, J̌alayirtai, who remained in the theater of operations, achieved no particular success. According to
The Secret History of the Mongols, around 1239–1240, Yesüder-Qorčin ‘...was sent to assist J̌alayirtai-Qorčin, who had long been on a campaign against the Solangɣas
100. <...> In subsequent years, J̌alayirtai, having successfully survived the era of interregnum, awaited his finest hour”
101.
Thus, it can be confidently asserted that Saritai and Čelodai are two different individuals, moreover, Čelodai may be considered Saritai’s successor in many ways: both held the highest positions in the Mongol army a quarter of a century apart, both commanded raids against Koryŏ, and both likely originated from the same tribe or clan.
In 1253, as already mentioned, Qa’an Möngke appointed Čelodai as commander of the eastern army: “In the spring of the 4
th year [of Xiànzōng’s reign] <…> the Emperor sent Qorči to conquer Koryŏ”
102.Čelodai was very active; in the 7
th month of 1254, he crossed the Amnokkang River, conducted a series of devastating raids on fortresses and villages, and presented the Koryŏ court with a condition: immediate surrender and the introduction of Mongol customs into the country
103. In the 1
st month of 1255, he left Koryŏ with part of his army, but returned in the 9
th month and established himself in Sŏgyŏng (P’yŏngyang)
104, periodically sending separate detachments to plunder the local population, including southern provinces, and exchanging messages with the Koryŏ court about the need to pay tribute and for the king to return from Kanghwa Island. Mongol soldiers received an order forbidding plunder only in mid-1257, after a member of the ruling clan, Prince Yŏngan Wang Hŭi (永安公王僖 영안공왕희), arrived at Čelodai’s camp, presented him with 100 silver bottles (
ŭnbyŏng), wine, and fruit, and also secured an agreement that the Mongol army would withdraw if the crown prince personally visited the court
105.
The latest record of Čelodai’ political activities is dated to the 3
rd month of 1259, when the commander was informed that the last representative of the Ch’oe military clan, Ch’oe Ŭi (崔竩 최의, 1233–1258), had been killed, and the Koryŏ government had made a final decision to swear vassal allegiance to the Mongol ruler, for which purpose the crown prince was prepared to arrive in Mongolia in the 4
th month
106. Initially, Čelodai had insisted on the king’s personal arrival, but Kojong was too old for the journey; and in a month the commander himself passed away.
Fuboda and Yesuder
Starting in 1254, under Čelodai’s command were two military commanders – Fuboda and Yesuder, as well as a member of the ruling clan, Prince Yŏngnyŏng Wang Chun (永寧公王綧 영녕공왕준, 1223–1283), who from 1241 lived in the Mongol state as an honorary hostage, married a Mongol noblewoman, and cooperated with the Mongols until the end of his life, and Hong Bogwŏn.
The identity of Fuboda (Ch. 甫波大 Fǔ
bōdà, Kor. 보파대 Pop’adae, ?–?) is extremely difficult to establish, despite his repeated mentions in
Koryŏsa and
Koryŏsa chŏryo. In 1254, he was attached to Čelodai’s staff: “It was ordered that taejanggun Yi Chang go to the Mongol garrison at Pohyŏnwŏn and present gifts [in the form of] gold and silver vessels [for wine], deer skins, silk, and other [items] to the commanders Ch’aradae, Yŏsudal, and Pop’adae, as well as to Yŏngnyŏn-
gon Wang Chun and Hong Bogwŏn “
107. Four years later, in 1258, he participated in the campaign against Koryŏ with the rank of chiliarch (unit of a thousand) commander: “The Mongol [commanders] Yŏsudal and Pop’adae, each with their detachment of thousand horsemen, encamped at Kaju (modern Unjŏn county, P’yŏngan-Pukto Province. –
Auth.) and Kwakchu (modern Kwaksan county, P’yŏngan-Pukto Province)”
108; the chronicle does not indicate the route of their further advance. Kang Chaegwang suggests that Fuboda (Pop’adae) may have led the detachment that attacked the Kiamsŏng fortress in Sŏngju (modern Samdŏk district, Sŏngch’ŏn county, P’yŏngan-Namdo Province) in the 1
st month of 1259
109, with his thousand constituting the main striking force. It is known that a detachment of
Yabyŏlch’o and the residents of Sŏngju, acting together, won at that time the greatest victory over Mongol troops in the territory of the Northern Region (Pukkye) during the final stage of the invasion (1254–1259), the only victory achieved through cooperation between the military, the government, and the civilian population. According to Kang Chaegwang, Fuboda moved south from his initial base in Kwakchu towards Unjŏndo and Sunju, and then attacked Kiamsŏng fortress
110.
Fuboda is not mentioned in Chinese chronicles, nor in
The Secret History of the Mongols, nor in any other sources available to us, so it is impossible to establish his real name. It can be assumed with great caution that his name, like those of Saritai and Čelodai, derives from a toponym or ethnonym, or else represents an indication of his official position or social standing. The latter is more probable, since it is known that in the Mongol state under the Genghisids, tribal divisions were abolished and gave way to divisions by
tümen and branches of the military, as a result of which the ethnonyms of those Mongol tribes that played a significant role in the pre-imperial era were preserved on the periphery of the empire, and in addition to them, a number of new ones appeared, based on military affiliation. Thus, there existed the term and ethnonym
Ba’atud, derived from
ba’atur,
batyr,
baɣatur (“warrior, hero”), analogous to the previously described term qorčin; the word
ba’atud itself is formed by adding the affix -
d to the word
ba’atur111. In Mongolia, the Mongol (including Oirat) ethnic group
Ba’atud (Baɣatud, baatud, baɣatud, Mong. Baatuud?, ᠪᠠᠠᠲᠦᠳ ᠪᠠᠭᠠᠲᠦᠳ?) still lives today. If we assume that the word
fuboda consists of two parts –
fǔ 甫 (“father; elder”) and
bōdà 波大 – a transformed phonetic derivative of
ba’atud /
ba’atur – then this name could be interpreted as “father-hero”, “elder hero”, i.e., a major influential military commander. He could also have been Chinese or a descendant of the Balhae people, given that the surname Fǔ (甫) still exists in China; in that case, his name in transcription should be written separately: Fǔ Bōdà. However, these are only conjectures; the only thing that can be stated with certainty is that this commander was not a Genghisid.
Yesüder (Ch. 余愁達 Yúchóudá, Kor. 여수달 Yŏsudal, Ch. 余速禿 Yúsùtū, Kor. 여속독, Mong. Yesüder-Qorčin, Yisüder Qorči, ?– after 1260) hailed from the Jirkin tribe (Mong. Jürkhen, Jürkhin, Zürkhen, which belonged to the Nirun branch of the Mongols)
112, and thus was also not a Genghisid. The Secret History states regarding him: “Concerning Yesüder-Qorčin, who was sent to assist J̌alayirtai-Qorčin, who had long been on a campaign against the J̌ürčet and the Solangɣas, an order was issued appointing him as the local
basqaq of the
tanma”
113. As Mikhail V. Gorelik writes, “in the Genghisid empire, non-Mongol military units were called
tanma, and they were commanded by special commanders called
tanmachi (in Turkic –
basqaq)”
114. That is, Yesüder was the commander of a detachment recruited from representatives of a non-Mongol ethnicity.
In
Koryŏsa, he is first mentioned together with Fuboda in the above-mentioned record of 1254, and in 1258 they both participated in the campaign against Koryŏ with the ranks of chiliarch commanders. Nevertheless, Yesüder apparently held a higher position than his comrade and enjoyed a certain degree of autonomy, as he independently conducted negotiations with representatives of the Koryŏ court: “When the King went to Ch’ep’ogwan, Kim Bojŏng reported [the following]: ‘Yŏsudal threatened me, saying: “Do you know that the Emperor has entrusted me and J̌alayirtai with all matters [concerning] Koryŏ? I will decide on [further] actions depending on whether your country surrenders. [Even if] the king does not come to the mainland [to] greet me, if you send the crown prince to surrender [before] our troops, [I] will withdraw [my] troops that very day. Otherwise, I will advance my troops south”. [Then I] replied that the crown prince would definitely come and see [him]’”
115. In the following year, 1259, Yesüder apparently accompanied a certain high-ranking Mongol commander, Sōngjí
dàiwáng (松吉大王, Kor. 송길대왕 Songgil
taewang, ?–?), whose identity we have been unable to determine, on a trip to Dōngjīng (Liáoyáng) to meet with the Koryŏ crown prince Wang Sik (王植 왕식), the future King Wŏnjong (元宗 원종, r. 1259–1274). The prince, as mentioned above, arrived to testify to his state’s loyalty to Mongolia and presented the two commanders with silver, ceramic and silver jars and vases, wine, and fruit
116. As a result of negotiations, military actions were finally halted, and Koryŏ recognized its vassal dependence on the Mongol state.
At the very beginning of King Wŏnjong’s reign, who ascended the throne in mid-1259, Yesüder sent a decree to Koryŏ regarding the establishment of a postal relay service: “In the regions south of Sŏgyŏng, postal stations shall be established throughout the country and provided [with officials], post horses, and [all necessary] supplies. [Furthermore], the postal stations north of Sŏgyŏng [shall be] fully equipped [according to] requirements”
117. In 1260, there are several records of disloyal officials surrendering to Yesüder, indicating that the state apparatus was gradually submitting to the Mongol administration. It is unclear whether Yesüder himself was on Korean territory at this time or received those who surrendered through intermediaries. The last mention of him in
Koryŏsa is from the 7
th month of 1260: “Please arrange for the dispatch of items intended for tribute and for presentation to Yesüder”
118.
Conclusion
As a result of this research, the biographies of ten commanders who led Mongol military campaigns against the state of Koryŏ in the pre-Yuan period have been reconstructed. Some of them are known to modern Korean and Mongolian studies scholars, like Saritai, while others have hitherto remained outside the field of researchers’ attention, for example, Amuqan and Fuboda. Among them were representatives of the highest nobility – the clan of Genghis Khan (Qachi’un, Yegü, and possibly Tangut), a Jurchen representative of the ruling house of Eastern Xia (Tege-Qorči), and Mongols representing various tribes: J̌alayir (Saritai and Čelodai); possibly Barghut (Amuqan), Jirkin (Yesüder); with a lesser degree of probability, Ba’atud (Fuboda); regarding Púlǐ Dàiwán, his ethnic affiliation could not be determined at this stage of research. All of these men held high positions in the Mongol army: Qachi’un led the army and embassy that arrived in Koryŏ in 1218; Saritai rose from Qachi’un’s deputy to the title of quán huángdì (viceroy of the Great Khan) and led the major campaign of 1231–1232; Púlǐ Dàiwán personally visited Kaegyŏng in 1221 and communicated with king Kojong, and in 1231–1232 was attached to Saritai’s staff; Tege-Qorči and Tangut also participated in the campaign of 1231–1232, with Tangut taking Saritai’s place after his death and leading a new raid in 1236; Amuqan in 1247 and 1252, and Yegü in 1252 led detachments that raided the northwestern regions of Koryŏ and received embassies from the capital; Čelodai directed the major military campaign of 1254–1259; Fuboda and Yesüder served under him with the rank of chiliarch commanders, and their position allowed them to receive Korean embassies and negotiate the establishment of suzerain-vassal relations.
The reconstruction of biographies of these ten Mongol commanders makes a twofold contribution to the study of the subject. First, it fills a conspicuous lacuna in Russian and international historiography, where scholarly attention has traditionally been concentrated on the political and diplomatic aspects of Koryŏ–Mongol relations, while the individuals who actually executed and, in many cases, shaped imperial policy on the ground have remained obscure or insufficiently differentiated. By systematically collating fragmentary information from Korean and Chinese sources, this study establishes a prosopographical foundation that enables future research to move beyond generalized references to “Mongol military commanders” and to analyze the campaigns through the prism of specific actors with their distinct clan affiliations, career trajectories, and personal motivations. Second, the diversity of ethnic and social backgrounds among the commanders examined, ranging from members of the Chenghisid lineage and Jurchen nobility to representatives of various Mongol tribes (such as the J̌alayir, Barghut, Jirkin, and possibly Ba’atud) calls into question the monolithic image of the Mongol expeditionary forces as a uniform entity. This heterogeneity not only sheds light on the internal mechanisms of the Mongol military machine, but also invites a reconsideration of how inter-tribal connections, personal rivalries, and status considerations may have influenced the conduct of military operations and negotiations with Koryŏ in the mid-13th century, prior to the establishment of vassal-suzerain relations with the Yuan Empire.
A more nuanced understanding of these biographical details carries significant implications for the historical narrative of the period. The fact that certain commanders, such as Saritai, rose from subordinate positions to supreme authority as the khan's viceroy, while others, like Fuboda and Yesüder, though serving as chiliarchs, nonetheless acted as authorized negotiators with Korean envoys, attests to a more flexible and pragmatic system of command than has often been assumed. Likewise, the inclusion of Qachi’un and Yegü – figures known primarily for their kinship to Chenghis Khan rather than for military achievements in Korea – underscores that the Mongol presence on the peninsula was not merely a series of military incursions, but also an instrument of dynastic politics and a symbol of imperial authority. These observations, when integrated into the broader scholarly discourse, along with factual material collected and analyzed in this study, make it possible to refine the chronology of early Koryŏ–Mongol relations, to revise prevailing generalizations regarding the strategic priorities of the Mongol Empire in Northeast Asia, and to offer a more nuanced framework for comparing Mongol expansion into Korea with contemporary campaigns in China and Central Asia. Thus, the present study not only restores to these long-overlooked figures their rightful place in history but also provides a methodological model for future prosopographical research on the history of Mongol imperial administration. It will also allow, to a certain extent, to fill the existing gaps in the study of biographies of those remarkable individuals who exerted a noticeable influence not only on the foreign, but some cases domestic, policy of the state of Koryŏ.
Notes
Reference list
- Bira, Shagdaryn. Mongol’skaya istoriografiya (XIII-XVII vv.) [Mongolian Historiography (13-17th centuries)]. Moscow: “Nauka”, GRVL, 1978.
- Bol’shoi akademicheskii mongol’sko-russkii slovar’ [Large Academic Mongolian-Russian Dictionary] / Ed. А. Luvsandendeva and Ts. Tsedendamba; ed. inchief. G.Ts. Pyurbeev. Vol. IV. Moscow: “Academia”, 2002.
- Breuker, Remco E. “And now, Your Highness, we’ll discuss the location of your hidden rebel base: Guerrillas, Rebels and Mongols in Medieval Korea”. Journal of Asian History. Vol. 46, No. 1 (2012), pp. 59-95.
- Chu Ch’aehyŏk 주채혁. “Ch’alla and Saritai “ 札剌와 撒禮塔. Collection of Scholarly Articles on Korean History for the 60th Anniversary of Professor Kang Jinch’ŏl “강진철교수 화갑기념 한국사학논총” (姜晉哲敎授華甲紀念韓國史學論叢). Historical Studies Association, “Historical Collection” 역사학연구회, “史叢”. Vol. 21·22 (1977), pp. 283-302.
- Drobyshev, Yuliy I. “Tangutskoe gosudarstvo v russkikh letopisyah” [The Tangut State in Russian Chronicles]. Pis’mennye Pamiatniki Vostoka, volume 20 (2023), no. 1 (issue 52), pp. 70-83.
- Dyakova, Olga V. “O vremeni padeniya chzhurchzhen’skogo gosudarstva Dun Sya (Vostochnoe Sya)” [On the Timing of the Fall of the Jurchen State of Dongxia (Eastern Xia)]. Obschestvo I gosudarstvo v Kitae [Society and State in China]. Vol. XLIX. Part 1. Moscow: Institute of Oriental Studies of RAS (2019), pp. 207-213.
- Gorelik, Mikhail V. “Cherkesskie voiny Zolotoi Ordy (po arheologicheskim dannym)” [Circassian Warriors of the Golden Horde (Based on Archaeological Data)]. Arheologiya evraziiskih stepei [Archaeology of the Eurasian Steppes]. №5 (2017), pp. 280-302.
- Henthorn, William E. Korea: The Mongol Invasions. E.J. Brill, 1963.
- Hoyt, Sandji K. Etnicheskaya istoriya oiratskih grupp [Ethnic History of Oirat Groups]. Elista, 2015.
- Istoriya Korei [The History of Korea]. Vol. 1. Moscow: “Nauka”, GRVL, 1974.
- Juvaini, Ata-Malik. The History of the World-Conqueror / Trans. by J.A. Boyle. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1958.
- Kang Jaegwang 강재광. “The historical significance of the victory in battles of Kiamsŏng and Sŏngju in North Region in 1259” 1259 년 북계 成州岐巖城戰鬪 승전의 역사적 성격. Journal of Military History. No. 136 (2025), pp.81-117.
- Ke Shaomin 柯劭忞. Xin Yuan shi (New History of Yuan [Empire]) 新元史. [Electronic resource ]. URL: https://ctext.org/wiki.pl?if=gb&res=201395 (last accessed: 28.02.2026).
- Khapachevsky, Roman P. “Annaly Hubilaya”, glavnyi istochnik po istorii pravleniya pervogo imperatora dinastii Yuan (tsuani 4-17 “Yuan shi”) [“Annals of Qubilai” as the Main Source on the History of the Reign of the First Emperor of the Yuan Dynasty (volumes 4-17 of Yuan shi)]. Transl and comment. by R.P. Khrapachevsky. Moscow: TSIVOI, 2019.
- Koryŏsa (History of Koryŏ [State]) 고려사. Annals of Generations 세가. Biographies 열전. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://terms.naver.com/entry.naver?docId=1672520&categoryId=62163&cid=62131 (last accessed: 28.02.2026).
- Koryŏsa chŏryo (Essentials of Koryŏ History) 고려사절요. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://db.history.go.kr/goryeo/itemLevelKrList.do?itemId=kj&types=r (last accessed: 28.02.2026).
- Koryŏsa chŏryo II. Essentials of Koryŏ History. Translated by Edward J. Shutlz and Hugh H.W. Kang.Yonsei Korean Studies Series No. 1. Seoul, Jimoondang, 2014.
- Kozin, Sergei A. Sokrovennoe skazanie. Mongol’skaya hronika 1240 goda pod nazvaniem Monгol-un niгuča tobčiyan. Yuan chao bi shi: Mongol’skii obydennyi sbornik [The Secret History. Mongol Chronicle of 1240 Named Monгol-un niгuča tobčiyan. Yuan chao bi shi: Mongolian Commonplace Book]. Vol. 1. Introduction to the Study of the Monument. Translation, Texts, Glossaries. Moscow, Leningrad: Academy of Sciences, 1941.
- Ledyard Gari. “The Mongol Campaigns in Korea and the Dating of ‘The Secret History of the Mongols’”. Central Asiatic Journal, Vol. 9, No. 1 (March 1964), pp. 1-22.
- Munkuev, Nikolai Ts. Nekotorye problemy istorii mongolov XIII v. Po novym materialam: V 2 tomah: issledovanie yuzhnosunskih istochnikov [Some Problems of 13th-Century Mongol History Based on New Materials: In 2 Volumes: A Study of Southern Song Sources]. Doctor of History Thesis. Moscow, 1970.
- Rashīd ad-Dīn Fazlullah’s Jami’u’t-tawarikh. Compendium of Chronicles. A History of the Mongols. English Translation & Annotation by W.M. Thackston. Harvard University, Dept. of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations, 1998.
- Starinnoe kitaiskoe skazanie o Chingishane [Ancient Chinese Story about Genghis Khan]. Translated from Chinese by Archimandrite Palladius. Oriental Collection. Volume one. Saint-Petersburd: Printing House of the Ministry of Railways, 1877.
- The Case of Zhù Gǔyŭ’s Murder 著古与遇害案. Baidu Encyclopaedia (百度百科). URL: https://baike.baidu.com/item/著古与遇害案/63075386 (last accessed: 28.02.2026).
- The Secret History of the Mongols: A Mongolian Epic Chronicle of the Thirteenth Century / Transl. and Comment. by Igor de Rachewiltz. Vol. I-II. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 2004.
- Tikhonov, Vladimir M., Kang, Mangil. Istoriya Korei [The History of Korea]: in 2 vol. Vol.1. From Ancient Times till 1904. Moscow: Natalis, 2011.
- Tongguk pyŏnggam (Military Overview of the Eastern State) 동국병감. Transl. and comment. by Kim Seŏkhyŏng 김석형역주. P’yŏngyang: State Publishing House 평양 국립출판사, 1955.
- Wen Tingshi 文廷式. Yuán Gāolí jìshì (Chronicles of Koryŏ [State] in the Yuan Era) 元高麗紀事. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://db.history.go.kr/goryeo/level.do?itemId=cnwk (last accessed: 28.02.2026).
- Yoo Byungjae 류병재. “A Study on a Relationship between Mongol Empire and the Jin Dynasty Seen Through the Mongolisti Names of Having been Recorded in History of Jin”『금사(金史)』에 기록된 몽골인명(人名)을 통해 본 몽골·금(金) 관계 연구. Mongolian Studies 몽골학, 52, (2018), pp. 77-133.
- Yoon Eun-Sook 윤은숙. “The Character of Koryo-Mongolia War and Changes of the Attitudes of Mongolia” 麗∙蒙 전쟁의 성격과 몽골의 태도 변화. Gangwon History 江原史學. No. 24∙25 (2011), Inseok Choi Bok-gyu Professor’s Commemorative Festschrift for Retirement 仁石崔福奎敎授定年紀念論叢, pp. 113-129.
- Yuan shi (History of Yuan [Empire]) 元史. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://ctext.org/wiki.pl?if=gb&res=434890 (last accessed: 28.02.2026).
- Yuan shi shizu biao (Genealogical Tables of Clans and Lineages [Mentioned in] the History of Yuan [Empire]) 元史氏族表. Volume 1. Ancient [Clans] 卷一. 旁古. [Electronic resource]. URL: https://ctext.org/wiki.pl?if=gb&chapter=313976&remap=gb#p8 (last accessed: 28.02.2026).
- Zhapova, Dugvema N.-D. Funktsional’naya evolyutsiya proprial’noi leksiki (na materiale antroponimii mongol’skih yazykov) [The Functional Evolution of Proprial Vocabulary (Based on Anthroponymy in the Mongolic Languages)]. Ph.D. in Philology Thesis, Abstract. Ulan-Ude, 2004.
- Zlygostev, Valery A. Geroi “Sokrovennogo skazaniya” [Heroes of “The Secret History of the Mongols”]; ed. V.A. Ivanov. Ufa: “Alfa-Reklama”, 2018.